Saturday, 23 February 2013

New vs Old Games Journalism

 
New vs Old Games Journalism
 
 
This was a great discussion in lecture today as it opened my eyes to the difference between new and old games journalism. In the following blog I will starts by explaining my own opinions on the differences between the two, I will then lead on to post two different article locations (one of each) to show the difference. Finally I will summarise by giving a conclusion on which I believe is the best form of games journalism.
 
 
Old Games Journalism:
 
This form of journalism is the type I expected to find regarding games, this method focuses and analyses the separate parts that form the video game such as graphics, gameplay, interface and control. This would be seen as a more factual style article. You would normally see this type of article written as a 'pro's and con's list' or in paragraphs of text in an overview.
 
 
New Games Journalism:
 
I was mostly unaware that this type of article existed until today's lecture (I previously always used IGN for reviews and previews etc.). This would be best described as an article written by the writer/player responding to the experiences presented to them in the game world including interacting with other players online. This is a more personal form of article as it is based off that particular writer/player's opinion while playing the game. You would normally associate this type article written as though reading from a story book.
 
 
Example Journals:
 
NGJ http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/games/archives/game_culture/2005/03/ten_unmissable_examples_of_new_games_journalism.html

From this page I read Possessing Barbie which is about age notifications for players in an avatar based MUD.


OGJ
http://uk.ign.com/games/world-of-warcraft/pc-16985

This article is a summary of the game World of Warcraft.


Conclusion:

After reading the two above articles, you will see the difference straight away. However, which type of journal article is superior?

My answer is that neither is superior, they both have good points and bad points as follows:

A NGJ is much easier to read, you can be absorbed into reading the article with great interest much like reading a story book, it can set a clear picture in your head of the scenario that the player is in. The downside is that these articles can miss out on key game information. If you are looking to buy a game but want information on it before buying then this type of article could prove less informative as it is based on a single persons playing experience. What could make one person interested could cause another person to be bored.

An OGJ will provide you with key game information if you are looking for facts about a game before purchasing. However, to make it to the end of the article may prove difficult as they can be long and tedious . Again this type of article is based on the writer/players opinion, but this time it is opinions of game rather than the personal experience while playing.

I believe to create a great computer game journal, you would need to merge ideas from both NGJ and OGJ. You could have a pro's and con's list at the start of an article with bullet pointed information  (could include fact and opinion), it could then lead on to give you an idea of the game from the writers personal point of view while playing the game. This could include the writer/players feelings felt and experiences gained while playing.

Sunday, 17 February 2013

Gender & Games

 
Gender and Games
 
Triple-A Games:
 
 
In an article on Gamasutra, there was a discussion about triple-A games for women. Ernest Adams says that while women may play small or free games, not many women will not pay out for triple-A console games for themselves.
 
He then goes on to question Brandii Grace about her founding a company to make triple-A games for women. From this interview, I have pulled the following key pieces of information:
  • Current triple-A games on the market are custom maid to suit men more than women. The themes and executions of these games don't support the needs or attitudes of female audiences, (Difference between Twilight and Underworld in films).
  •  
  • A successful big title game that did attract a lot of female players was 'The Sims' due to interpersonal conflicts between AI characters in the game. These types of mechanics would include deception and alliance manipulation.
  •  
  • Men obtain fun from overcoming challenges within games, however in many cases women can be deterred by challenges as they are so averse to the risk of failure. Only 10% of women play for the challenge.
  •  
  • Comparisons are made between games released on the Nintendo Wii & Xbox Kinect and core games released on the same consoles. This indicates that women head more towards the family friendly and socially interactive games and consoles, however the example given in the interview for the Xbox Kinect game 'Kinect Adventures' lead to a biased result statistic as the game is included for free when the Kinect is bought.
  •  
  • Allowance for local multiplayer games where players can join and drop out as and when they please. Not currently many games on the market that permit this.
  •  
  • Advertising and distribution to be related to the product / game theme. The examples given are to advertise women's games in women's magazines or cooking games in cooking magazines, and to distribute games including PoS (point of sale) in related areas such as cooking games being sold next to recipe books etc.
 
 
     
     
     

Friday, 8 February 2013

Story in Games


Story in Games
 
For today's lecture we covered 'The Nature of Stories' written by Chris Crawford (2005) On Interactive Storytelling.
 

Story Structure:
 
All stories required strict structural requirements to be classified as a story. The example given by Chris Crawford is the children's nursery rhyme 'Itsy Bitsy Spider', this four line rhyme contains a clear simple story. It has a protagonist (spider), conflict (rain), struggle (being washed out), resolution (crawled back up) and even a moral (the value of perseverance).
 
The key areas that are usually used to structure a story are as follows:
  • People (characters) - All stories are based around a character. What a story needs to do is focus on the role of those people within the story and less upon items/objects/things. Stories such as Lord of the Rings and The Legend of King Arthur could be argued with this point as they contain key objects which seem to be central to the story, however they do not actually play the main piece of the story. In LotR the story is based on Frodo's struggle during the adventure, if the ring was replaced with a magic sock, the story would not have changed by much whereas if Frodo was swapped out for Han Solo then the story would change considerably.
  • Conflict - Conflict always seems to play a part in stories in two different forms. Direct conflict which is the most common of the two as it is the easiest to implement in film and games, examples of this would include fights, wars, races etc. The other form would be indirect conflict, which is more commonly found in books as it is easier to portray with written words, examples of this would be more social or symbolic such as a characters personal dilemma or an argument/debate between people.
  • Puzzles - Puzzles can play certain parts in stories and would even be a large part of story in a mystery story. However the puzzles used in stories are actually primarily about the people/characters. Puzzles are not a necessity to form a story.
  •  
  • Choices - Choices are ultimately the decisions that people/characters make within the story. Important points in stories are usually revealed by key choices made by the protagonist.
  • Spectacle - Spectacle is most commonly found in film and computer games as it is a visual form of 'pleasure from novelty' by providing exotic imagery as a form of entertainment. Films and games are continually striving to provide better graphics and spectacle for the audience. However, due to the increased amount of spectacle used within film and games, it tends to sacrifice story. A lot of younger audiences would associate spectacle with story, but spectacle is another element that is not a necessity for story.
 
 
Visual Thinking:
 
Observers have noted that in the modern day the use of imagery is rising and the use of written words is declining. This can be shown through amount of effort put into increasing the quality of images and CG (computer graphics) along with the amount of money consumed in doing so for research and development. Plus the size of images as data can be equated to megabytes whereas text would be kilobytes.
 
When you read a book, your understanding of the story is formed as an image in your head, however, it is written word that puts the image there. So without a book, if you think of the life of an item, the image provided in your head is from what you have read or seen previously - the more detailed the reading, the more vivid the image.
 
Spatial Thinking:
 
My understanding of spatial thinking is how the brain uses your imagination to fill in blanks within reasoning and stories. An example I would use is to describe a character/person in England in one chapter of a story and the next chapter they are in Spain. Different people would imagine different scenarios and images in their heads for how the character got from England to Spain, such as via multiple forms of transport or by flying there like superman. This spatial thinking is your brain making logic and order of things within a story and is only limited to your individual imagination.
 
Temporal Discontinuity:
 
Stories can be broken up into sections using stages or chapters etc. However, they can also play and make use of time - breaking up, jumping backwards and forwards, and skipping time altogether. Time in stories created drama as it treated completely different to normal physical time. Examples of this would be flashbacks, skipping years with "many years later..." and simultaneity shown via "meanwhile, back at.....". Storytelling using time, can be easily used by both visual and written forms of entertainment.

Friday, 1 February 2013

Remediation


Remediation: Games
 
In today's lecture we stared looking at remediation, looking at the definition and also the way it is used in today's society and finally looking at remediation in films and games.

Matteo Bittani, (2003), The Technoludic Cinema: Images of Video Games in Movies (1973-2001).
Jay Bolter & Richard Grusin (2000), Remediation: Understanding New Media, MIT Press.
 
To sum up the definition of remediation, it is to use one form of media for another purpose and that remediation is the defining characteristic created from that new purpose.
 
 
Forms of Remediation:
 
Immediacy - The aim to make a viewer be wholly drawn into the experience making them forget seeing or watching. Examples could be immersive virtual reality or photo realistic images.
 
Hypermediacy - Items/media that purposely calls attention to their own constructed nature all the time. Examples of this could be video game HUD's and the WWW.
 
 
Examples would include:
  • Photo realistic paintings similar to photography.
  • Forms of the WWW are commonly used on TV and TV advertising used on the Internet.
  • 3D imaging on flat surfaces is now used on TV's and computer consoles but originated from a painting in 1430.
  • Wide screens used in technology were originally used in landscape paintings.
Why Remediation is Used:
 
There are multiple reasons. It can take a long time for a new medium to develop new forms of content.
 
Another reason would be to improve upon an existing media, an example of which could again be computer games. They stared out as 2D pixels on a screen but have since become 3D and more photo realistic. Companies are still taking computer games further and further until the point in which a new form of media is created in which video games can be played.
 
If a form of media is successful it is more likely to be remediated, computer games had the intention to become 3D from the start. Also variety TV programmes took the successful idea from radio which in turn had originally started out from music halls.
 
 
Technoludic Films:
 
Technoludic films are a combination of Technology and Ludus (Latin for Play).
 
Technoludic Film as Commentary - Video games are subordinated to the film. Example movies would be 'The Lawnmower Man' (1991), 'Existenz' (1999), 'The Matrix Triology' (1999ff).
 
Technoludic Film as Quotation - Games appear in the film for illustrative purposes. They are not central to the theme of the film but form part of the fictional world the film is trying to create. Example movies would be 'Blade Runner' (1982), 'Clockers' (1997), 'Inception' (2010).
 
Technoludic Films as Remediation (1) Adaption - Films using a direct adaption of games as a source of text for the film. Example movies would be 'Super Mario Brothers' (1993), 'Lara Croft: Tomb Raider' (2001), 'Dead or Alive' (2006).
 
Technoludic Films as Remediation (2) Incorporation - Films that incorporate the narratives and/or style traditionally found within computer games. Example movies would be 'Groundhog Day' (1993), 'Toy Story' (1995), 'Run Lola Run' (1998).


Thursday, 24 January 2013

Game Britannia Episodes 2 & 3

 
Games Britannia
 
Episode 2 - Monopolies and Mergers
 
 
From the start of this episode, Benjamin Woolley leads on to explain about how board games have affected and influenced the British society over the past 200 years by teaching a wide audience of people valuable morrals.
 
 
The first game looked at was Monopoly. This game was created with various playing boards globally, depicting different landmarks and areas based on the version of the board while keeping the same game rules and mechanics. There were many releases, the one we all know was based on London landmarks, with American board versions using landmarks from New York etc.
 
What I didn't realise about Monopoly was that it influenced by another game called 'The Landord's Game' also named 'Brer Fox & Brer Rabbit'. This game was very similar, however it taught players the value of fair play while pointing out the differences in classes of people with how land taxes were extremely unfair compared to taxes based on income. So it pulled in and laid bare the social inequalities of that time while keeping the game fun and teaching players the benefits of equality and fairness.
 
Woolley then goes on to explain that during the great depression, board game companies decided to help families through this time by creating games such as Cluedo and Scrabble, these games are popular games that most households have even today due to how families can come together to play.
 
Towards the end of the episode, Woolley shows how the popularity and production of board games has declined due to the rapid advancements in technology. However, board games today are still using the original idea of teaching players about the happenings around the world but with changes or improvements that water the information down, making it into a more family friendly fun game.
 
 
 
Episode 3 - Joystick Generation
 
 
With this final episode of Games Britannia, Woolley shows how classic board games moved on to the first fantasy RPG, and also how board games turned a new leaf into modern day computer games.
 
The first fantasy RPG game that was created which derived from classic board games was 'Dungeons & Dragons' (this RPG is also massivly popular even today). This game was created as a distraction from real life during the great depression to a fantasy game where people would role play a made up character from a fictional world. Players could make whatever choices they wanted in the game (even to extreme measures that would oppose the normal characteristics of the player) and creating narrative which further emerses the players into the fictional fantasy of the game.
 
It was from the idea of Dungeons & Dragons that the first computer games were born. Due to the success from the unique play style, simulation games were created for computers which gave players similar choices to those in D&D, such as Rolercoaster Tycoon, Theme Hospital and The Sims - again creating and taking players from their imperfect worlds to their fantasy perfect worlds.
 
From these examples we can see the link between board games to computer games and for this reason we see why the those particular board games should not be forgotten.
 
Finally, Wooley goes on to show that players create deep emotional connections to the characters within modern day computer games. We see examples from Grand Theft Auto, to see how players can relate to a character such as the main character in the game, and be lead to do things like steal cars and kill innocent people. We only have to look back at the history of games to see why players can make these choices - a complete opposite to choices made in real life. Players can see the consequences of their actions in an unreal environment without the penalties that they would recieve in real life.


Monday, 14 January 2013

Caillois Terminology


 
Caillois's Terminology
 
 
In this lecture we looked at the different terminology that Caillois uses for describing types of games or gameplay, (all information was obtained from the notes provided by the tutor in the lecture).
 
The following are the words and their descriptions:
  • Paidea - Refers to 'Play' as pleasure.
  • Ludus - More restrictions due to rules with clear outcomes (example 'winning').
(Examples of a Paidea type game would be SimCity or The Sims. There are also games that allow players to switch between these two modes).
 
The following four terms, Caillois adapted from Huizinga:
  • Agon - meaning Competition.
  • Alea - meaning Chance or Randomness.
  • Ilinx - meaning Movement.
  • Mimicry - meaning Situational, Make-Believe or Role-Play.
 
My Examples:
 
Now from these words and definitions, I will try to come up with some games as examples for each of the four categories under the two modes.
 
Examples of Paidea Games:
 
Agon - Theme Hospital (and many other simulation type games).
Alea - Tetris (untimed version just playing for high scores).
Ilinx - Skipping (and other sports that could be made into games - hopscotch etc.).
Mimicry - Dungeons and Dragons (live acting version where people act out the story).
 
Examples of Ludus Games:
 
Agon - Monopoly
Alea - Poker
Ilinx - American Football
Mimicry - Final Fantasy (console games)
 
 
Conclusion:
 
From the above, I can say that my examples of Ludus games were much easier to find. However based on the definitions provided for the above terms I believe that there are many games that overlap on both the term types and modes, so it is therefore hard to extract pure examples for any one game type. For example, The Sims and SimCity have restrictions and boundaries within the game's mechanics so therefore you could argue that it is not necessarily a Paidea game but rather a Ludus game. Also games tend to have all four terms (Agon, Alea, Ilinx and Mimicry) rolled into one such as Monopoly.
 
So my conclusion and opinion on the above words used by Caillois is that although it may be useful to summarise descriptions into a single word, they are not however clear cut distinctions. 

Thursday, 3 January 2013

Games Britania - Dicing with Destiny


Games Britania - "Dicing with Destiny"
 

 
In this lecture we watched episode 1 of Games Britania presented by Benjamin Woolley. This was for us to understand when and how games stared centuries ago.
 
In this game, Woolley explores some of the oldest games known (in their original forms) and explains how these games may have been played at the time.
 
 
The Stanway Game:
 
The first game to be looked into was the Stanway Game which was excavated in Stanway in 1996 from graves of British people (when Britain was under Roman rule), however once uncovered from the graves these pieces were believed to be from around 43AD. The graves were referred to as 'the Doctor's Grave' and 'the Warrior's Grave'.
 
From this excavation, a board with metal corner pieces and glass playing pieces found on opposing sides of the board were found from the Doctor's grave (already set up as if a game was being played) however the rules are unknown. This is where Woolley decides to consult Irving Finkel (who states it is probably a strategy game predating the Roman invasion) and Mike Pitts (to get an idea of the original owner of the game).
 
 
Alea Evangelii:
 
Alea Evangelii (Game of Angels) was a game mentioned in a manuscript, (including diagrams), alongside Athelstan who was the C10th King of Britain. This was believed to be the game of his court.
 
Woolley plays this game with David Howlett. This game is part of the Tafl group of games where there are twice as many attacking pieces as there are defending. The defending pieces are based in the center of the board surrounding a king with the object of the game in getting the king to escape via one of the corners (or sides) of the board. A piece can capture another of the opposing side by surrounding him (a piece on either side) and if the king is captured then the attacking king wins.
 
The game board is an 18 by 18 grid with 72 playing pieces in total.
 
 
Nine Men's Morris:
 
This game was found scratched into stone within a medievil cathedral. This is a form of naughts and crosses, however if a player manages to get 3 in a row they then get to remove an opponent piece (rather than an instant win).
 
 
Hazard:
 
A gambling game using dice throws (therefore chance), believed to bought back to Europe by crusaders in the C14th. However this game was looked down upon by the church and was banned for a period of time due to this.
 
 
Faro:  
 
A card game which bought about a peak in gambling in the C18th. Due to this game, a murder trial took place in 1823 involving James Thurtell who was the son of the Mayor of Norwich. He was convicted and hung of murdering another man over a gambling debt, this later led to The Gaming Act in 1845.
 
 
The Royal Game of Goose:
 
This game was bought about showing that not all games are evil, this game was about virtue and used a spinner rather than dice. This was a simple board game of 63 squares played in the Victorian times.
 
 
Gyan Chapoor:
 
Woolley decided to play this game. This was the original form of 'Snakes and Ladders' and was of Hindi origin, believed to be the game of knowlege in which players must reach a state of enlightement in both the game and in life. The board to this game is much larger than normal snakes and ladders and has areas that can be reached rather than just one direction.
 
 
Chess:
 
The original pieces in this game were named after Howard Staunton. He later standarised the pieces and rules for all to play (which ended up being world wide) for the first international chess tournament in 1851.

Wednesday, 28 November 2012

The Grand Poobah Iterations


The Grand Poobah
 
 
In today's lecture, after discussing our findings from the previous week's reading, we started looking at the game 'The Grand Poobah' with the aim of iteration around the 'space of possibility' and 'pacing' from "Space of Possibility and Pacing in Casual Game Design - A PopCap Case Study" by 'Marcos Venturelli'.


First Play Through - Original Game:

The game itself was fairly simple. One deck of cards shuffled and face down, one player (from four or five) becomes the Grand Poobah (players choose), that player then turns the top four or five cards face up based on the number of players playing, the grand poobah then distributes those card to whichever player he likes (including theirself). Players then tally the scores from the round (red cards count for scoring points), the grand poobah keeps track of these scores each round, and then finally voting begins to decide who will be the Grand Poobah for the following round (decided by black cards). The first player to reach 70 points wins.

Red Ace - 10 = 1-10 points respectively.
Red J - K = 10 points each

Black Ace - 10 = 2 Votes
Black J - K = 3 Votes
Red Ace - K = 1 Vote

The game was fairly fun to play for a short while, however due to the Negative Feedback Loop in the game, towards the end it became tedious due to the loosing players gaining more points to overtake the winners which repeated itself throughout the game. This caused the game to take a long time and it didn't let the winner pull off in front at any point meaning anybody could win, there was no point at which loosers could prepare to lose and the winner could prepare to win. The drop in the dramatic arc of the game ("Tools for Creating Dramatic Game Dynamics" - Marc Leblanc), was so sudden and in some cases unexpected that it didn't give players the desired effect.


Implemented Iterations:

Our iterations for this game were all (but one) theory based as we didn't have time to implement them during lecture.
 
Our actual implemented iteration was for players to receive 3 'hidden energy' cards at the start of the game which the players could choose to use whenever they like. These cards would be used to swap out the card dealt by the grand poobah. An example of the ideal situation to use these cards would be to swap out a Red Ace that was dealt (as these only score one point and only gain one vote), with a Red King from your hidden cards (this instead would cause the player to score 10 points).
 
We never finished playing this version of the game as we realised it didn't work in making the game more enjoyable, but from this iteration we realised that to keep this element even and workable, the hidden card needed to be randomly picked from the deck's royals otherwise a player could end up with all bad hidden cards. To balance this, each player would have 2 hidden cards rather than 3.
 
Iterative Ideas:
 
The ideas I came up with for possible iterations were:
 
  • When the grand poobah distributes the cards, they distribute them facedown so that nobody can see what is dealt before tallying the points and casting the votes, this would cause blind voting. An alternative to this would be for the only player to see the delt cards would be the grand poobah.
  • Another form of hidden energy, that goes against the powerful negative feedback loop, would be for the selected winner of the voting stage to gain a token for each round voted. These could be used when the player likes to empower the amount of votes they cast in a round (the player can choose to keep these hidden from other players for extra strategy).
  • A player states who they are voting for and then roll the dice (hidden from other players views) and only reveal the outcome once each player has decided and rolled. The amount of votes is decided on the dice roll per player totalled.
  • Players could play to 100 points, for the first player to reach every 25 points (25, 50, 75), they can choose to knock out a player of their choice. (I also thaught about the idea of countering a 'knock out' if they still currently hold a hidden energy card - this would be used if the knock out idea was too powerful once tested).
  • When a player becomes the grand poobah, they gain a seperate token. Once 5 tokens have been collected they can be traded in a set amount of points.
  • Players could have a set amount of lives each (10?), for each round the player who is last on the points list will loose a life. Once all the lives are lost, that player is knocked out of the game.


Conclusion:

From these iterations, I would have play tested each one to see if they work - making adjustments as necessary. But from the one iteration they we did implement, we realised how hard it would be to get around the negative feedback loop in this game. This was the main feature in the unaltered version and was an extremely powerful tool, to try to change this or removing it from the game would potentially make the game completely different.

Wednesday, 21 November 2012

Book/Article Readings - PopCap Games


Week 5 Reading


This weeks reading is "Space of Possibility and Pacing in Casual Game Design - A PopCap Case Study" by 'Marcos Venturelli'. My source for this information was pulled from LearnUCS on Blackboard learn.



The Topic:

Investigation into design principles that relate to casual game development. Concentrating on aspects relevant to Pacing and using PopCap Games (2000) as the study point due to their market relevance and critical acclaim.


Introduction:

Nintendo is one of the main catalysts for the rebirth of expressions such as 'accessibility' and 'family friendly', however these sort of games can now be found in online networks for both Xbox 360, PS3 and PC. However, there is still a black hole in terms of how 'casual games' are designed and the fundamentals of building a casual game.

Games such as Tetris and Pacman are being remade, played and reassessed. Even though these games are much more simple than those which are usually developed this era, we realise that casual game design does in fact use several elements of games past.


Casual Games:

Casual Games "generally involve less complicated controls and overall complexity in terms of gameplay or investment required to get through a game" - (IGDA's Wiki website Casual Games 2009). However, further to this general definition, there are disagreements with concepts of this statement.

These said casual games are not necessarily of lesser complexity in terms of the mechanics or in the production. An example game released by PopCap Games to support this is 'Plants Vs. Zombies' which becomes considerably complex at times. 'Rayman Raving Rabbids' developed by Ubisoft has huge production values.

Marcus states that for the purpose of the work covered in the article, 'Casual Games' would be considered as games that offer the possibility of 'pick up and play', and experiences that can be enjoyed in small bursts but can be interrupted by the player without any form of penalty. The key element would not be the complexity of the system and its mechanics, but how the complexity is presented to the player.


Pacing:

Pacing within a game is a concept related to the overall rhythm of the game, the speed at which the different moving parts of the system are put in motion. By using the MDA (Mechanics, Dynamics and Aesthetics), designers create relaxation, tension, repetition through which they control the pace.

Threat - Generated on a level of game mechanics existing as the power struggle leans in favour of the system or the players opponent(s). The actual power of the opposing forces against the player.

Tension - The perceived danger that the player might become the weakest side of the conflict. Graphics and sound/music can increase this tension.

Movement Impetus - The will or desire of a player to move forward through a level, however not limited to level design, it determines how willing the player is to make 'advancement decisions' which represents his/her interest to keep playing the game.

Tempo - The 'intensity' of play. The time between each significant decision made by the player. Higher tempo creates slower decision making and lower tempo creates more frantic decision making.


Space of Possibility:

'A game is designing place of possibility, the creation of structure that can play out in complex and unpredictable ways, a space of possible actions a player explores while playing a game. It is the collection of all possible actions and outcomes inside the designed space of the game, (all artificial outcomes made possible by the system).' 

The space of possibility can be linked directly to the complexity of the game which then in turn is related to tempo. If you limit the space of possibility for potential outcomes before making moves, this creates more 'fun' and 'challenge' in a game (especially timed games) due to not having to over think situations. Doing so could slow down a game's progress to the point where it becomes boring or frustrating especially if a player is forced to make a decision without feeling that they have assessed all the possible outcomes.

From this we can see that a 'pick up and play' type of casual game is one that has little or no tutorial or extra instructions, therefore the learning happens as the game progresses so that the player is not required to invest too much time learning the patterns.

The most commonly used solution to balancing the player tempo is via layering within a game, mechanics used to raise the difficulty of the game for the player as they progress.

Instead of constantly adding new features to a game, an alternative solution is to 'replace' a current feature with another (improved) one. However balancing these (both adding and replacing) features would lead to great design of a game, an example of which is PopCap's 'Plants Vs Zombies' which is highly addictive and successful game. This game's design principles and main focus is to keep constantly high 'Player Impetus' through the whole experience - referred to as 'Upper Arch' of pacing.

By including and balancing Threat, Tension, Movement Impetus and Tempo a game can reach a constant state of 'Flow' which makes the player feel like they can't stop playing. (Dropping Tension and Threat considerably when the mechanics of a game change, helps balance the game accordingly to the changes - allowing the player time to adapt to the changes).


Conclusion:

After going through the article as I posted this blog, I realised just how important it is to balance Threat, Tension, Movement Impetus and Tempo to make great game titles such as Plants Vs Zombies. This is a game I have personally played and found really addictive, so I can say first hand that the game is easy to 'pick up and play' and then hard to put down again.

Now having a deeper understanding of each of the pace mechanics (above), I will now be able to more easily include and iterate games using these concepts in the hopes of creating a game with re-playability.

Wednesday, 14 November 2012

Book/Article Readings - Chance & Skill

Week 4 Reading

The information and references for this weeks reading was obtained from "Brenda Braithwaite & Ian Schreiber (2008) Challenges for Games Designers. Charles River Media" - chapters 5 & 6.


Chance

Chance games include card games, most  RPG's (through the use of variable damage and random encounters), and rock-paper-scissors. Chance games are created to encompass a wider audience as they become winnable by anybody regardless of player skill.

Where chance is not used in games, they become solvable, meaning the entire possibility space is known ahead of time. This causes such games to be exploited and then less compelling. Once the player solves the game, it looses part of what makes it a game in the first place. However not all solvable games are automatically bad, such as chess, it is solvable but the possibility space is large enough to stay entertaining. The smaller the solvability space there is in a game, the less interesting the game becomes. Adding random elements into these games helps keep it fresh due to preventing players from 'mastering' the game.

Competitive games do not suit all audiences, such as a parent and child, as the matching is not equal. This would lead to repeated defeat, boredom or frustration. Adding random elements into this type of game would give less experienced players a chance to win. It also softens the blow of a defeat.

Games with no random elements will often start in the same way and players will make the same strategic choices throughout the game. Adding in a random element to this would make players encounter a wider variety of situations, therefore if used in the right way it can increase the players experience and thus increasing re-playability.

Random elements also create dramatic tension, this helps with games such as RPG's and RTS's which rely on this tension, creating exciting and compelling circumstances.


Mechanics of Chance:

A variety of game mechanics used to implement chance are as follows:

  • Dice
  • Cards
  • Other Game Bits - such as spinners, coin flipping and a dreidel.
  • Psuedo-Random Number Generators - although computers are driven by non random instructions, using specific algorithms it becomes close enough to chance (such as random encounters and damage numbers in RPG's).
  • Hidden Information - It is non-random information but when concealed from the players, it is random from their perspective.

Randomness is not created equal. 'Measured Randomness' is where the nature of the random elements are known and can be planned for by the players. An example of this is dice rolls - the more dice there are the higher the outcome of a result.


Skill

Strategy is powerful as it makes the players come back to play again, this is due to players wanting to master the game based on varying strategies formed from their understanding of the game's dynamics. Game designers pre-plan and create this into their games wherever possible.

From it's core, a good game is a series of interesting decisions, and good games cause players to use and test their skills but then rewarding them with immediate and obvious feedback.

When players and constantly making decisions, they enter a state of 'flow' (as per psychologist Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi). 'Flow' is an optimal play style and one which games designers work hard to achieve.


Types of Decision:

A players skill in a game is determined by the decisions the player makes and the weight of those decisions, to how those decisions affect the outcome of the game.

  • Obvious Decision - having a choice but choosing the 'obvious' outcome required to progress or win, as the alternative choice may lead to a negative outcome.
  • Meaningless Decision - A choice with no right or wrong answer, having no outcome in the game therefore making the choice irrelevant.
  • Blind Choices - A choice made with no previous information provided, equally important but not very interesting. These choices can be turned into other choices by giving the player enough information.
  • Tradeoffs - A decision made when a player doesn't have enough resources to accomplish all their goals. This type of choice can lead to important decisions but can become obvious if the choice is not evenly weighted.
  • Dilemnas - All choices lead to the players harm. (An example of this choice would be the video we watched in class on 13/11/12).
  • Risk Versus Reward (Tradeoff) - A choice from a situation with multiple outcomes with each choice having different levels of risk but greater rewards given to the higher the risk taken.

Mechanics of Skill:

  • Tradeoff - Used via auctions and purchases. Where a player must sacrifice something to gain another.
  • (Dynamic) / Limited Use Special Abilities - The choice of when to use a specific skill as it may be a one time use.
  • Explicit Choices - Choice by giving the player the information for both outcomes.
  • Limited Actions - An example of this would be choosing to move a specific play piece over all others given that only one play piece can be moved per turn.
  • Trading and Negotiation - Used in games with multiple players, it is used in both competition and co-operation.

Conclusion

This reading has given me examples of existing tools in the field that I will be able to utilise in designing and  creating my games during my course.

Most of the tools listed and examples given are ones which are self explanatory that we as designers would take for granted, but from this reading we understand their full meaning and where we should expect to use them. Some of the tools described, we would expect to see in most if not all of today's games.

Tuesday, 13 November 2012

Bibliography Task


Online Library Resources

During today's lecture we had moved rooms for our meeting with Sarah Robinson to discuss different ways to access resources online. She had shown us how to use the summon searchtool and also UCS OPAC, (from these I found the summon searchtool to be most useful).

We also covered the importance of bibliographies and how to record them with ease through the use of RefWorks. We were also shown the web plugin called Zotero which is another bibliography recording tool, however, I personally prefer RefWorks due to how it works with the online UCS Library.
 

Task:
 
Our objective or task for this session was to use the databases shown and provided previously to find two full length books, two contributions to books (otherwise known as 'readers' or 'anthologies') and two articles in refereed journals, for a particular topic (within the games design course) and to record them in a bibliography.

(RWUCSuffolk) - RefWorks Info.

My chosen specific area was 'Character Design' for which I found the following reading materials by using the summon searchtool and then recording the findings in RefWorks:

(The following layout of the above is based on the 'Harvard Referencing' system).
  1. Reader 1 'Armstrong, H. (2009) Graphic design theory: readings from the field. New York: Princeton Architectural Press'.
  2. Reader 2 'Corneliussen, H. G. and Rettberg, W. J. (2008) Digital culture, play and identity: A World of Warcraft reader. Cambridge (Mass.): MIT Press'.
  3. Book 1 'Hartas, L. (2005) The art of game characters. Lewes: Ilex'.
  4. Book 2 'Tillman, B. (2011) Creative character design. Oxford: Taylor & Francis Ltd'.]
  5. Journal 1 'Gustafson, J. (1990) 'Design a Character', The Reading Teacher 44 (1) 86-87'.
  6. Journal 2 'Triantafyllakos, G., Palaigeorgiou, G. and Tsoukalas, I. A. (2010) 'Fictional characters in participatory design sessions: Introducing the “design alter egos” technique', Interacting with Computers 22 (3) 165-175'.

Friday, 9 November 2012

Book/Article Readings - Dramatic Tension

Week 3 Reading


This weeks reading was an article of Marc Leblanc, and how he introduces us to mechanics we can use to create dramatic tension in games.

"Tools for Creating Dramatic Game Dynamics" - Marc Leblanc.

This article can be found in the book "The Game Design Reader  - Katie Salen and Eric Zimmerman - published by MIT Press (2006)" but is not yet available online. For the purpose of this Blog and reading for the week I pulled my information from the article that is posted on Blackboard Learn within LearnUCS.


From the start, LeBlanc shows that there are two types of story in games. The first being a traditional story told through the narrative of the game, much like a traditional book. The other is through the way a game is played and the events of the game itself, such as sports making it into the newspaper or a game of chess - the plans, bluffs, strategies or maybe the reversal of one's fortune. This type of play can lead to a climax, through struggle to a satisfying conclusion, this is how LeBlanc defines 'Dramatic'.

Players seek out drama within games as a type of fun, this is a part of a game's play content, therefore designers aim build drama into their games.


Drama within MDA Framework:

Aesthetic model for Drama - Drama is one of many aesthetic models. The below image represents drama via the use of a graph:



The main point of this graph is to see that dramatic tension can increase and decrease. Dramatic tension is the level of emotional investment in the story's conflict. With the feelings such as concern, apprehension and urgency with which players await the story's outcome.

Game designers have a greater challenge of creating drama even when they have no direct control over narrative, but instead emerges through the events of the game.

Conflict is required for dramatic tension to take place, this can be used through the contest from which a game is built such as challenges of intellect or stamina or competition between multiple players. Tension comes from conflict in two ways, both of which are required:
  1. Uncertainty - A sense that the outcome of the game is still unknown. Any player could win or lose.
  2. Inevitability - The sense that the contest is moving towards resolution. The outcome is imminent.
Both of the above are independent of each other, they are evoked using different systems and dynamics, which makes it easier for a designer giving finer control over each element separately for tuning and adjusting. When uncertainty and inevitability intersect, this gives rise to the peak of dramatic tension.

Most techniques that imbue dramatic tension use two main approaches, 'force' and 'illusion', (a ticking clock/timer is a common example of these):
  • Force is manipulating the state of the contest itself. We make a game close because we limit how much advantage one player can have over another.
  • Illusion is manipulating players to make the game seem closer than it actually is.

The feedback system used in conjunction with uncertainty:
  1. The Game State - examples would be a save game function or the name of a level with each individual object within it or even the time left on a clock.
  2. Scoring Function - numeric value given to players as a measurement to see who is winning and by how much.
  3. The Game Mechanical Bias - the rule of a game which gives one player an advantage over another.
  4. The Controller - the rule of the game that decides which player receives the mechanical bias with the decision being made from the scoring function.
An example of the above system is the 'Negative Feedback System' which keeps the game close by bringing the score function closer towards zero. The 'Positive Feedback System' would be seen as the opposite, striving to keep the difference in score as large as possible.

The negative feedback system is a powerful tool in creating dramatic tension as it keeps the game uncertain, players won't know the outcome of the game as the scoring difference would be as close to zero as possible, therefore creating dramatic uncertainty. When aiming towards the end of a game, using the positive feedback system is useful for dispelling uncertainty, bringing about the climax and a sense of finality. Using only the negative feedback system can cause games to go stagnate, so positive feedback systems are needed for breaking the equilibrium and moving a game forward. (I picture this as a fog covering land at the start of day, with the sun coming out later - clearing the fog and leading one side to victory).


Pseudo-Feedback is a mechanism used to create game dynamics that make a game appear as though it is being driven by a negative feedback system, however there is no actual cybernetic feedback system at all.

Escalation is a game mechanic used to make the score gain get faster and faster as the game progresses so more points are at stake at the end of the game than there were at the start.

Hidden Energy is another tool used, and example of this could be 'turbo fuel' on a racing game, each player has and equal amount of hidden energy at the start of the game but the timing of using this fuel can change the outcome. This mechanic creates dramatic uncertainty by manipulating the players incomplete understanding of the true score of the game.

Fog of War is a mechanic used to create dramatic uncertainty by limiting the information available to players. As a game progresses, more information becomes available.

Decelerator is used as an obstacle that slows down players later in the game, making it seem that the game is closer than it actually is by changing the scale and pace of the game.

Cashing Out is another mechanic used. An example of this would be if a player wins a round of a particular game, the start of the next round bother players start even, but the first player to get three wins will win the game. This shows that the player who wins the first round will not necessarily win the game, however it does give them a greater chance at winning as they are one win closer than the opposition.

From the above mechanical systems I personally believe Cashing Out is the least used of the five as it appears to be the most complex.


Conclusion:

Again, this article proved to be informative as it provided technical names for the design tools we use when creating drama and dramatic tension within games. It helps us pinpoint each area we need to concentrate on for future projects.
I agree with each of the examples used by LeBlanc, and feel like I know exactly what he means through the use of planting an image inside my head as I read each paragraph.


Wednesday, 7 November 2012

Book/Article Readings - MDA


Week 2 Reading


This week we were tasked with reading 'MDA a formal approach to games design and games research - by Robin Hunicke, Marc LeBlanc and Robert Zubek'.

http://cs.northwestern.edu/~hunicke/pubs/MDA.pdf


Abstract:

The idea for the MDA framework (Mechanics, Dynamics and Aesthetics) was aimed at bridging the gap between game design & development, game criticism and technical game research.

Like Doug Church's article on FADT, this places a common terminology for use when describing games from a designer's point of view.


Introduction:

Iterations support and help analyse the end result of a game to refine implementation, and then analysing those implementations to refine the result.

Designer -- (Creates) -- Game -- (Consumed) -- Player

Games are created by designers/developers and consumed by the players. They are purchased and used to then eventually be cast away like other consumable goods.

The difference between games and other entertainment products such as books, music, movies and plays is that the 'consumption' is fairly unpredictable. What happens during the gameplay and the outcome of the events are unknown at the time the product is finished.

MDA Framework:  Rules - - - System - - - Fun


Mechanics - 'Components at the level of data representation and algorithms'. 

Dynamics - 'The run time behaviour of the mechanics based on player inputs and each other's outputs over time'.

Aesthetics - 'The desirable emotional responses evoked in the player when interacting with the game system'.


From Point of Designer:  (Mechanics - - - Dynamics - - - Aesthetics)


Designers Perspective - 'Mechanics give rise to dynamic system behaviour which turns to aesthetic experiences'.

From Point of Player:  (Aesthetics - - - Dynamics - - - Mechanics)

Players Perspective - 'Aesthetics set the tone, born from observable dynamics and eventually, operable mechanics'.


Aesthetics:

The following words are examples that can be used in place of the word 'fun' to better describe individual key areas within games:

  1. Sensation - Game as sense-pleasure.
  2. Fantasy - Game as make believe.
  3. Narrative - Game as drama.
  4. Challenge - Game as obstacle course.
  5. Fellowship - Game as social framework.
  6. Discovery - Game as uncharted territory.
  7. Expression - Game as self discovery.
  8. Submission - Game as pastime.
Using the above words as examples in the following games:
  1. Charades - Fellowship, Expression, Challenge.
  2. Quake - Challenge, Sensation, Competition, Fantasy.
  3. The Sims - Discovery, Fantasy, Expression, Discovery.
  4. Final Fantasy - Fantasy, Narrative, Expression, Discovery, Challenge, Submission.

Dynamics - 'Work to create aesthetic experiences within the game such as time pressure and opponent play'.

Mechanics - 'Various actions, behaviours and control mechanisms afforded to the player in game context. Mechanics support overall game play dynamics'.


Conclusion

From my understanding of the reading, I believe using certain words to describe key areas within game, it helps us as designers focus (when iterating) on the correct areas.

I also think that the framework of the MDA  in general is pretty solid in the sense that designers create (produce) a game, players buy (consume) the game then give feedback via forums etc after the launch of a game. (Play testing would give designers the same required information however changes could be implemented before release). This then enables designers to work on key areas for improvement in the future. This helps us understand the importance of iteration.




RTS Game Iterations


Week 3


As per our normal routine for this lecture we started by discussing what we had found out from the reading required over the past week. http://critgamestuds.blogspot.com/2012/11/bookarticle-readings.html.

Once we had finished discussing what we understood from this article, it was time to put theory into practice.


RTS Game (Real Time Strategy):

Our lecturer Rob had created a game for us (in groups) to play with the aim of iterating into a better game. This was by far the hardest game to iterate so far.

From playing the game the first time with no iterations, we found that it was pretty much impossible to kill each other due to the game mechanics (unless a player was not paying attention). So our first change to the game would be a small one to try to fix this issue.


Iteration 1 - We had simply changed the order in which a player takes their turn, making it so that 'Fire' would always be first, followed by 'Move' and then lastly 'Turn & Move'.

This iteration seemed to have fixed the issue where players couldn't kill each other. So we then moved onto changes that would increase elements of fun within the game.


Iteration 2 - This round we had added in weapon drops with a variety of weapons each having unique characteristics, there was a limit to how many of each weapon there was in game and to also how many weapons each player could carry at a given time. An example weapon would be 'shotgun' having a range of 4 squares out but a wider radius of 3 squares wide.

We found that this iteration had increased the fun of the game in the following ways, using the 'MDA' framework:

  1. Challenge,
  2. Sensation,
  3. Competition,

We were about to move onto a third iteration of improving the game's Aesthetics via the board which would also change the Mechanics, but we had run out of time for the lecture.


Conclusion:

From this lecture we had come up with some great ways to improve the game play but we found it difficult coming up with ideas initially while sticking to the game's core mechanics.

Sunday, 4 November 2012

Snakes & Ladders Iterations


Week 2

    This week's lecture consisted of the group discussing our findings from the week's previous read (which can be found on my previous post: http://critgamestuds.blogspot.co.uk/2012/10/bookarticle-readings.html), and then moving onto iterations for the classic game of 'Snakes & Ladders'.


    Snakes & Ladders:

    As per normal, we started by playing the original game from which we would try to identify areas that we could work on and make ammendments (hopefully improvements) increasing fun and replayability.

    For our fist iteration we decided to make the snakes 'fightable'. To do this if a player landed on a snake head, they would roll the dice against the opposite player (who would be rolling for the snake), if the snake's roll won then the player would move down the snake as normal plus another 2 squares back. If the player won the roll then they could ignore the snake head. To add a strategy into this we also added in two way movement, meaning that on the player roll they could decide to move either backwards or forwards. An example of this would be if the player rolled a '5', if moving forward they would land on a snake head they could get the chance to stay there (on beating the snake's roll) or they would fall down 2 levels. Or the player could move backwards still putting them behind the opponent but not as far as the snake would have taken them.

    Our next iteration was to roll an exact number to finish, making it harder to complete while getting more competative at the end. We also wanted to increase the board size but there was not enogh room on the paper to do this.

    From these iterations we decided the game was still too heavily based on chance, so using 'Doug Church's tools', we wanted to give the players more 'Intention'.

    Our next iteration was to take out the dice for movement. Instead we obtained a pack of playing cards, using all decks we used cards 1-6 and the 4 Kings. We shuffled this smaller deck and then dealt them out, four per player to begin with. We decided that movement would be based on the numbered cards and Kings would be used to climb ladders or counter falling down snakes. Every time a card was played (one per turn), that player would then pick up another as replacement so that four cards were always in hand. A player always had to move if they could, not allowing players to choose to miss turns. We also decided to keep in the previous iteration of finishing on an exact number.

    This iteration worked really well, even though the cards dealt were random, we always had four cards in our hand to choose from for movement.

    Our final iteration was to incorporate Doug Church's tool 'Story'. We came up with the idea of players choosing at the start of the game to be either a 'Firefighter' or a 'Snake Whisperer'. If you were a firefighter, you would climb ladders and fall down snakes and if you were a snake whisperer, you would climb snakes and fall down ladders. We also used the idea of King's being able to counter an opponenets king when used for climbing.



    Conclusion:

    Overall through our few iterations, and through playtesting (including another person from outside our group) we decided the game was now much more fun to play and more competative.



    Friday, 2 November 2012

    The Royal Game of Ur


    The Royal Game of Ur

    For this week's lecture we looked into the Royal game of Ur (otherwise known as 'game of 20 spaces' by Irving Finkel - due to there being 20 square tiles on the playing board).


    At first we briefly looked at peoples categorisation of games, namely Finkel (referring to Murray), Bell, and David Parlett.

    Finkel (2008) refers to Murray (1952 - A History of Board Games Other Than Chess - Contents Page), classifies board games into five groups:
    1. Games of alignment and configuration (examples such as Noughts and Crosses and Nine Men's Morris etc.).
    2. War Games (such as Chess).
    3. Hunt Games (such as Fox & Geese).
    4. Mancala Games (such as Mancala).
    Bell (1960; revised 1980 - Board and Table Games from Many Civilizations - Contents and Bibliographies) sets games into six categories:
    1. Race Games (such as Pachisi).
    2. War Games (such as Chess).
    3. Games of Position (such as Noughts & Crosses).
    4. Mancala Games (such as Mancala).
    5. Dice Games (such as Hazard).
    6. Domino Games (such as Ma-jong).
    Parlett (1999 - The Oxford History of Board Games - Contents Page) places games into four categories:
    1. Race Games
    2. Space Games
    3. Chase Games
    4. Displace Games
    We discussed the differences and similarities between each persons categories, for example Murray considered the games of Fox & Geese as a 'hunting' game but for Parlett it is a game of 'chase' while for Bell it is a 'war' game. It was at this point that we looked specifically at 'The Royal Game of Ur'.


    The Board & Pieces:

    The layout of the original board which was first discovered in 2600BC from the ancient city of Ur, was shaped with a larger body area (4 x 3 squares), a smaller body area (2 x 3 squares) and narrow bridge area connecting the 2 previous areas (2 x 1 squares). 7 playing pieces were used for play. The rule-set for this game was on a clay tablet dating back to 177BC - the oldest known set of game rules in the world. Both the game board and tablet are now stored in the British Museum.

    The board was later found (early part of the second century BC) that the board layout had changed. The smaller area of six squares had been 'straightened out' and added to the bridge which extended the part of the board where two players were in conflict. This later version of the game was played with five pieces rather than seven, and the five gaming pieces are distinguished from each other and represented different birds (Swallow, 'Storm Bird', Raven, Rooster and Eagle).

    There were two types of dice found with the game board, 'throwing sticks' which were four sided, with the upper side representing the roll. The second dice found were tetrahedral (four sided) pyramid-shaped dice (otherwise known as D4). On a four sided dice, the outcome is decided by point which is uppermost, with two pints being marked giving the player two chances out of four in rolled a marked pointed side up roll.

    We then played the game ourselves to get a feel of what to do with the intention of making Iterations to the game with what we thought would increase the playability and fun.

    Playing the Game:

    Our first play through was the unaltered version. I found this game to be easy to learn and fairly quick to play and complete taking roughly 20 minutes. To finish the game we had to roll the exact number needed - this wasn't explained to us from the instructions, so we used this as a base rule. First game I won.

    Our first Iteration was to allow 'Crowing' of pieces when pieces from the same player entered the same tile allowing movement in bulk, there was no limit to the amount of pieces on a space so we decided not to have a limit for the 'crowning' of a single piece. This second play through was even faster and easier although it made for more aggressive gameplay due to being able to finish the game with '1 piece'. Second round, I also won.

    Our second Iteration was to allow a single roll to either be used for getting a new play piece onto the board OR for moving an existing piece, no longer being able to split the roll between both. The third play through revealed that this extended the duration of the game for people wanting a longer game. I also won the third game!


    Conclusion:

    'The Royal Game of Ur' is a fairly quick game that has the fun of games such as 'Droughts' and was easily moddable to change certain areas for increasing fun and playability.

    Wednesday, 31 October 2012

    Book/Article Readings - FADT

    Gamasutra - Doug Church - Features - Formal Abstract Design Tools

    For this week's reading (also my first reading), I had to read from Gamasutra for the topic 'Features - Formal Abstract Design' by Doug Church. For this article, I decided to read the online version from the following website:

    http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/3357/formal_abstract_design_tools.php


    In the article Doug Church talks about what modern day games are made of - a technical base with a vision for the players experience.

    He then explains how industry evolution has grown over the previous years such as more powerful hardware, better screens and audio equipment etc. However, he states that games 'Design' as a specific area has not evolved at such a pace and he believes this is due to the lack of a 'Common Design Vocabulary', such as engineers talking their respective jargon and doctors knowing Latin names for each body part. Games designers would just say 'that was fun' or 'that wasn't very good'.

    Doug then moves onto a notion for FADT (Formal Abstract Design Tools) as a way to use particular words to describe the 'Design' of a game, with hopes to help push the advancement and evolution of this area as much as the technical aspects mentioned above.


    FADT:

    There are four words used in this area:

    Formal - Precise definition which you are able to explain to others.
    Abstract - Emphasises focus on underlying ideas (not genre specific), such as '+2 Giant Slaying Sword' this would be specific to genre, instead you would say 'Player Power up Curve'.
    Design - Self Explanatory.
    Tools - Self Explanatory.


    Using Tools under FADT:

    Doug explains that there are many examples of tools that are used in games and would take and endless amount of time to go through each to explain. For this reason he gives us three examples to give us the understanding of how tools can be used in games to give players overall enjoyment while keeping the designer in control.

    Intention - (Intentionally) - 'Making an implementable plan of one's own creation in response to the current situation in the game world and one's understanding of the game play options.'

    Perceivable Consequence - 'A clear reaction from the game world to the action of the player.'

    (Both of the above two tool types are commonly used in conjunction. Example game provided by Doug Church was Mario 64).

    Story - Narrative thread, whether designer driven or player driven, that binds events together and drives the player forward toward completion of the game.

    (The 'Story' tool often conflicts with 'Intention' as a lot of control is taken away from the player, sacrificed for the use of narrative which is mostly if not fully designer controlled. Some RPG's such as Final Fantasy maintain a balance of both but keep them separate - Combat uses 'Intention' and Plot uses 'Story').

    Doug Church finalises that games differ from books and movies due to the above key core tools used to make players interact and become involved, making decisions to change outcomes.